Right-Left Asymmetry of Prefrontal Cerebral Oxygenation: Does it Depend on Systemic Physiological Activity, Absolute Tissue Oxygenation or Hemoglobin Concentration?

Background: We have repeatedly observed a right-left asymmetry (RLA) of prefrontal cerebral oxygenation of subjects during the resting state.

Objective: To clarify if the RLA is a reliably observable phenomenon at the group level and whether it is associated with systemic physiology, absolute tissue oxygen saturation (StO2) or total hemoglobin concentration ([tHb]).

Methods: StO2 and [tHb] values at the right and left prefrontal cortex (PFC) were calculated for two 5- min resting phases based on data from 76 single measurements (24 healthy adults, aged 22.0 ± 6.4 years). StO2 and [tHb] were measured with an ISS OxiplexTS frequency domain near-infrared spectroscopy device. In addition, end-tidal CO2 (PETCO2), heart rate (HR), respiration rate (RR) and the pulse-respiration quotient (PRQ = HR/RR) were measured and analyzed for the two phases.

Results: On the group level it was found that i) StO2 was higher at the right compared to the left PFC (for both phases), ii) RLA of StO2 (∆StO2 = StO2 (right)-StO2 (left) was independent of PETCO2, HR and PRQ, and iii) ∆StO2 was associated with absolute StO2 and [tHb] values (positively and negatively, respectively).

Conclusions: This study shows that i) RLA of StO2 at the PFC is a real phenomenon, and that ii) ∆StO2 at the group level does not depend on PETCO2, HR, RR or PRQ, but on absolute StO2 and [tHb]. We conclude that the RLA is a real effect, independent of systemic physiology, and most likely reflects genuine properties of the brain, i.e. different activity states of the two hemispheres.