• age 18 to 65 years; 2) documented PFO with medium-to-large shunts (≥ 20 microbubbles by c-TCD at rest or during the Valsalva maneuver); 3) history of embolic stroke (based on brain magnetic resonance imaging within 24 hours after symptom onset) or TIA within 6 months without other identifiable causes; 4) history of migraine for more than one year without other identifiable causes; 5) asymptomatic group: incidental finding of PFO in asymptomatic individuals, and presence of high-risk activities and/or anatomical features related to PFO (high-risk activities were defined as those in which the Valsalva maneuver was performed frequently or those that increased the risk of venous gas formation; and high-risk anatomical features included atrial septal aneurysm and/or curtain pattern on c-TCD).

• age 18 to 65 years; 2) secundum ASD size 10 to 20 mm, with sufficient surrounding rims, except the aortic rim; 3) right heart catheterization: resting SPAP \< 50 mm Hg, Qp/Qs ≥ 1.5 and PVR \< 5 WU.